When families think about a birth injury lawsuit, they often focus on the medical professionals who were present when the injury occurred. The delivering obstetrician, the nurse in the delivery room, or the physician who made the ultimate decision.
But birth injury litigation rarely focuses exclusively on those final moments.
As a birth injury lawyer, I investigate the entire course of labor and delivery, including the hours leading up to the injury. That often means taking depositions of nurses who cared for my client earlier in labor, even if their shifts ended long before the emergency occurred.
Why?
Because their testimony may help establish the timeline of care, identify early warning signs or reassuring clinical findings, clarify communications between providers, explain hospital policies, and reveal circumstances that are not apparent from the medical records alone.
Importantly, just because a nurse is being deposed does not mean they are accused of negligence or did anything wrong.
Depositions are not limited to the parties in a lawsuit. A deposition is a formal opportunity to obtain sworn testimony from someone who may have relevant information about the patient’s care. That testimony can support or challenge the allegations in a lawsuit.
Here are some of the reasons I may want to depose a nurse who cared for a patient before a birth injury occurred.
1. Establishing the Timeline of Care
One of the first things I do when investigating a birth injury case is reconstruct the timeline of labor and delivery.
I want to understand what happened hour by hour, including the patient’s condition, the fetal heart rate tracing, medications administered, communications between providers, and decisions made throughout labor.
Nurses are often central to establishing that timeline.
For example, a nurse who cared for the patient several hours before an emergency delivery may be able to explain what the fetal heart rate tracing showed, what interventions were attempted, and what information was communicated to the physician.
This testimony can help determine when a developing problem became apparent, whether there were opportunities to intervene, and how the patient’s condition changed over time.
2. Identifying Early Warning Signs and Reassuring Findings
A birth injury may become apparent during delivery, but the clinical evidence leading up to that moment can be equally important.
Depending on the case, I may ask a nurse about:
- Changes in fetal heart rate patterns, including recurrent decelerations or reduced variability.
- Excessive uterine contractions, including tachysystole.
- Maternal blood pressure changes or other concerning symptoms.
- The patient’s response to medications, including Pitocin.
- Changes in the patient’s condition that required additional assessment or intervention.
The critical questions are not simply whether a warning sign appeared, but whether it was recognized, appropriately evaluated, and addressed.
But I’m not only interested in abnormal findings.
Sometimes reassuring findings are just as important to the investigation.
For example, in a case involving hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE), I may want to understand whether the fetal heart rate tracing was reassuring earlier in labor and when concerning changes first appeared.
A nurse who cared for the patient before those changes occurred may provide important testimony about the baby’s apparent condition during that earlier period.
That information may help evaluate the potential timing of the injury and whether there was an opportunity to intervene before it occurred.
Of course, a reassuring fetal heart rate tracing does not definitively establish that a baby was uninjured at that moment or precisely when a brain injury occurred. Those questions require consideration of the entire clinical picture, including the fetal monitoring, neonatal condition, laboratory findings, imaging, and other relevant evidence.
But establishing what appeared normal can be just as important as identifying what went wrong.
3. Examining Communication Between Nurses and Physicians
Communication is a major focus of many birth injury investigations.
A nurse may recognize a concerning change in the patient’s condition but rely on a physician or another provider to make decisions about further treatment.
During a deposition, I may ask:
- When did you first become concerned?
- Did you notify the physician?
- What information did you communicate?
- How did the physician respond?
- Were additional orders given?
- Did you communicate your concerns to the next nurse?
These questions help establish whether important information was communicated accurately and whether the medical team responded appropriately.
They may also reveal situations in which a nurse recognized a problem and took appropriate action, but another provider failed to respond.
4. Understanding the Chain of Command
What happens when a nurse identifies a serious concern but cannot obtain an appropriate response from the physician?
Hospitals generally have policies addressing how nurses should escalate unresolved patient safety concerns.
These may involve contacting a charge nurse, nursing supervisor, department leadership, or another physician.
In a deposition, I may ask whether the nurse understood the applicable chain-of-command policy, whether it was used, and what happened when concerns were escalated.
I may also explore whether nurses felt supported in questioning a physician’s decisions or raising concerns about patient safety.
The existence of a policy is only part of the investigation. I also want to understand how that policy functioned in practice.
5. Clarifying or Challenging the Medical Records
Medical records are critical evidence in birth injury litigation, but they do not always provide a complete or unambiguous account of what happened.
A nurse’s deposition can help clarify entries that are vague, incomplete, inconsistent, or entered after the event.
For example, I may ask what the nurse meant by a particular chart entry, whether an intervention was performed at the documented time, or whether a physician was notified even though that communication does not appear in the record.
I may also ask whether the nurse independently remembers an event or is relying on the medical record to reconstruct what occurred.
The purpose is to understand what the documentation establishes, what it does not establish, and whether the testimony is consistent with the other evidence.
6. Understanding the Electronic Medical Record
Electronic medical records can create additional questions about documentation.
Depending on the system, entries may be automatically populated, copied forward, entered retrospectively, or associated with timestamps that require explanation.
A nurse familiar with the hospital’s electronic medical record may help explain how information was entered, where certain documentation appears, and what particular fields or timestamps mean.
In some cases, audit trails and other electronic data may also be relevant.
Understanding how the record was created can be just as important as understanding what the record says.
7. Investigating Staffing and Unit Conditions
Sometimes the investigation extends beyond the actions of an individual nurse or physician.
I may want to know what conditions were like on the labor and delivery unit during the patient’s hospitalization.
How many patients was the nurse assigned? Was the unit adequately staffed? Who was responsible for monitoring fetal heart rate tracings? Were physicians available when needed?
Were nurses managing multiple patients with competing clinical demands?
These questions may reveal whether staffing levels, available resources, or hospital systems affected the care provided.
They may also establish that the unit was adequately staffed and that the nurse had the resources necessary to provide appropriate care.
Either finding is relevant to understanding what happened.
8. Examining Hospital Policies, Training, and Competency
Hospital policies and training may become important when investigating whether medical professionals were prepared to recognize and respond to obstetrical emergencies.
Depending on the nurse’s role and knowledge, I may ask about policies involving fetal monitoring, excessive uterine contractions, physician notification, or emergency response.
I may also ask about training, competency assessments, and simulation exercises.
A charge nurse, nurse educator, or other staff member with leadership responsibilities may have additional knowledge about how nurses were trained and whether particular procedures were consistently followed.
Importantly, hospital policies do not automatically establish the legal standard of care. But they may provide relevant evidence about the hospital’s expectations, training, and actual practices.
9. Understanding Unit Culture and Informal Practices
Written policies do not always tell us how a hospital operates in practice.
Sometimes nurses can provide insight into informal routines, workarounds, or communication practices that affected patient care.
For example, were nurses encouraged to raise concerns about fetal heart rate tracings? Were there established practices for contacting physicians? Did staff feel comfortable escalating concerns when they disagreed with a provider’s assessment?
These questions may help explain how decisions were made and whether the hospital’s actual practices differed from its written policies.
Of course, testimony about broader practices must be relevant to the issues in the case and based on the witness’s personal knowledge.
10. Understanding Handoffs Between Nurses
Labor and delivery care often involves multiple nurses working across different shifts.
When one nurse’s shift ends, important information must be communicated to the next nurse assuming responsibility for the patient.
I may ask what information was included in the handoff, whether concerns about the fetal heart rate tracing or maternal condition were discussed, and whether there was a clear plan of care.
A nurse who left hours before the injury may have important testimony about the patient’s condition and the information provided to the incoming nurse.
This can help determine whether critical information was lost or misunderstood during a transition in care.
11. Confirming or Challenging Other Witness Testimony
Birth injury cases often involve testimony from multiple nurses, physicians, and other medical professionals.
Their recollections may not always align.
One provider may recall receiving a telephone call about a concerning fetal heart rate tracing, while another may remember a different conversation or timeline.
A nurse’s deposition may help confirm, clarify, or challenge testimony from other witnesses.
These differences do not necessarily mean someone is being dishonest. Memories fade, events occur quickly, and different providers may have different perspectives on the same situation.
My responsibility is to evaluate the testimony alongside the medical records and other available evidence.
12. Preserving Important Testimony
Birth injury lawsuits can take years to investigate and litigate.
During that time, nurses may change employers, relocate, or have difficulty recalling specific events.
A deposition preserves a witness’s sworn testimony about what they remember and what they know.
This can be particularly important when the nurse was present during an earlier period of labor that later becomes significant to the case.
Does Being Deposed Mean a Nurse Is Accused of Negligence?
No.
This is an important distinction, especially for nurses who may be unfamiliar with the litigation process.
Being an important witness is not the same thing as being responsible for the injury.
A nurse may be deposed because they observed something important, documented a critical event, communicated with another provider, or have knowledge about hospital practices.
Sometimes their testimony establishes that they recognized a concern and acted appropriately.
Sometimes it helps identify a breakdown in communication or a decision made by another provider.
And sometimes it confirms that the care provided was appropriate.
A deposition is not, by itself, an accusation of wrongdoing.
Why the Entire Course of Care Matters in a Birth Injury Case
One of the most important lessons from investigating birth injury cases is that the final emergency does not necessarily tell us when a problem began.
A baby may be delivered by emergency cesarean section after a prolonged period of concerning fetal heart rate patterns. A shoulder dystocia may occur after prenatal assessments and delivery planning decisions that deserve examination. A maternal complication may become catastrophic after earlier changes in the patient’s condition went unrecognized.
These examples do not automatically establish negligence. They illustrate why the investigation cannot always begin and end with the moment an injury becomes apparent.
As a birth injury lawyer, I want to understand the entire sequence of events.
That means reviewing the medical records, evaluating the clinical evidence, questioning the providers involved, and identifying witnesses who may have relevant information, even if they were not present when the injury occurred.
Because determining whether a birth injury was preventable requires understanding not only what happened, but when it happened, why it happened, and whether the medical team had an opportunity to change the outcome.
This article is provided for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal or medical advice. Deposition procedures, discovery rules, and standards governing medical negligence vary by jurisdiction. Every case depends on its specific facts and applicable law.