Shoulder dystocia is one of the most unpredictable emergencies in obstetrics. It occurs during vaginal delivery when, after the baby’s head is born, one or both shoulders become lodged and additional obstetric maneuvers are needed to complete the delivery.
Over the past several years, researchers have documented an increase in reported shoulder dystocia rates. But that raises an interesting question: Are shoulder dystocias actually happening more frequently, or are medical professionals getting better at recognizing and reporting them?
And there’s another important finding in the research. In some populations, shoulder dystocia diagnoses have increased while brachial plexus injuries have decreased.
As a birth injury attorney who investigates shoulder dystocia and brachial plexus injury cases, I think both trends deserve attention. They raise important questions about how these emergencies are identified, how providers are trained to respond, and what can be done to prevent injuries.
Are Shoulder Dystocia Rates Increasing?
The research suggests that reported shoulder dystocia rates are increasing, although the reasons are not entirely clear.
A large U.S. study published in 2023 examined approximately 9.9 million vaginal deliveries between 2016 and 2019. Researchers found that the reported incidence of shoulder dystocia increased from 2.1% to 2.46%, representing a relative increase of approximately 17% over four years. [1]
Similar trends have been observed internationally.
A Finnish population-based study of more than 800,000 deliveries found that reported shoulder dystocia increased from 0.10% in 2004 to 0.32% in 2017. [2]
A Swedish study examining nearly 1.9 million vaginal deliveries also found an increase in shoulder dystocia diagnoses between 1997 and 2019.[3]
These studies document increasing rates, but they don’t necessarily establish that shoulder dystocia itself is becoming more common at the same rate.
There are at least two possible explanations worth considering.
Explanation One: Changes in Maternal and Fetal Risk Factors
Certain pregnancy and delivery characteristics are associated with an increased likelihood of shoulder dystocia.
These include maternal diabetes, larger fetal size, elevated maternal BMI, and operative vaginal delivery.
Diabetes is particularly relevant because it can influence fetal growth patterns, including the relative size of the baby’s shoulders and trunk.
The U.S. study identified large-for-gestational-age infants and maternal diabetes among the strongest risk factors associated with shoulder dystocia. [1]
The Finnish study also documented increases in several maternal risk factors during its study period, including gestational diabetes, elevated BMI, and maternal age. [2]
These changes could contribute to a genuine increase in shoulder dystocia.
However, the relationship is not straightforward. Risk factors are associated with shoulder dystocia, but most pregnancies involving these characteristics do not result in shoulder dystocia. Conversely, shoulder dystocia can occur without any identifiable risk factors.
And changing risk factors do not necessarily explain the full increase in reported incidence.
Explanation Two: Better Recognition and Reporting
The second explanation is particularly interesting because shoulder dystocia has not always been consistently recognized, documented, or coded.
A 2024 study published in Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics examined shoulder dystocia diagnoses in a Finnish hospital district.
Researchers reviewed medical records and identified 537 cases of shoulder dystocia. Yet only 170 of those cases, approximately 32%, had been assigned the specific diagnostic code for shoulder dystocia.
In other words, more than two-thirds of the identified cases lacked the corresponding diagnostic code.[4]
The researchers also found inconsistent descriptions of shoulder dystocia in medical records, including references to difficult or tight shoulders without a corresponding diagnosis.
This matters because many large epidemiological studies rely on diagnostic codes to identify shoulder dystocia cases.
If shoulder dystocia occurs but is not consistently coded, the reported incidence may underestimate how frequently it actually happens.
The Finnish researchers also observed improvements in the use of recommended obstetric maneuvers and more consistent coding over time.4
Other researchers have suggested that increased awareness, simulation training, and improved documentation may contribute to rising shoulder dystocia diagnoses. [2,3]
Importantly, better recognition and more accurate reporting are positive developments.
Accurate identification helps clinicians prepare for future pregnancies, improves the reliability of research, and provides better information about how these emergencies are managed.
The challenge is determining how much of the increase in reported shoulder dystocia reflects changing pregnancy risk factors and how much reflects improved recognition and reporting.
The existing research does not provide a definitive answer.
But Here’s Another Interesting Trend: Brachial Plexus Injuries Are Decreasing
Shoulder dystocia is a major risk factor for obstetric brachial plexus palsy, sometimes called Erb’s palsy.
The brachial plexus is a network of nerves that controls movement and sensation in the shoulder, arm, and hand. Injury to these nerves during birth can cause weakness, limited movement, or, in more severe cases, permanent disability.
Given the association between shoulder dystocia and brachial plexus injury, one might expect increasing shoulder dystocia rates to be accompanied by increasing rates of these injuries.
But that is not necessarily what researchers have found.
In a Swedish population-based study published in 2023, researchers examined approximately 1.9 million vaginal deliveries between 1997 and 2019.[3]
During that period:
- Reported shoulder dystocia increased from 2.0 to 3.3 cases per 1,000 vaginal deliveries.
- Obstetric brachial plexus palsy decreased from 3.1 to 1.0 cases per 1,000 vaginal deliveries.
That represents an approximately 65% relative increase in shoulder dystocia diagnoses alongside an approximately 68% relative decrease in brachial plexus palsy.
The researchers examined whether changes in fetal birthweight and operative vaginal delivery could explain the decline in brachial plexus injuries.
Those factors explained only a small portion of the overall reduction.
The authors discussed improvements in shoulder dystocia management and the introduction of simulation-based training as possible contributors to better outcomes. However, the study was not designed to establish that training caused the decline.
Still, the findings raise an important question:
If shoulder dystocia remains an unpredictable emergency, can better preparation and management reduce the likelihood of injury?
What Does the Research Say About Shoulder Dystocia Training?
Some of the most compelling research comes from studies examining clinical outcomes before and after the introduction of structured shoulder dystocia training.
In 2008, Draycott and colleagues published a study comparing shoulder dystocia management and neonatal outcomes before and after mandatory simulation training was introduced at a hospital in Bristol, England.
The researchers found substantial improvements in the use of recommended maneuvers, including McRoberts positioning, suprapubic pressure, internal rotational maneuvers, and delivery of the posterior arm.
Documented excessive traction decreased from 16.7% to 9.2%.
Neonatal injuries associated with shoulder dystocia also decreased from 9.3% to 2.3%.[5]
A subsequent study by Crofts and colleagues examined outcomes over 12 years of shoulder dystocia training at the same hospital.
The incidence of brachial plexus injury among documented shoulder dystocia deliveries decreased across the study periods:
- Before training: 7.4%
- Early training period: 2.3%
- Later training period: 1.3%
The researchers also documented substantial improvements in the use of recognized shoulder dystocia maneuvers.[6]
These findings are significant.
They suggest that structured, ongoing training can be associated with improvements in both clinical management and neonatal outcomes. The findings provide meaningful support for the importance of preparing delivery teams to manage shoulder dystocia safely.
Why Training Matters When Shoulder Dystocia Occurs
Shoulder dystocia requires prompt recognition and an organized response.
McRoberts positioning and suprapubic pressure are commonly used first-line maneuvers, and many shoulder dystocias can be resolved with these interventions.
But not every shoulder dystocia responds to the initial maneuvers.
When additional maneuvers are necessary, the delivery team must be prepared to respond appropriately.
This may include internal rotational maneuvers, delivery of the posterior arm, or other accepted techniques depending on the clinical circumstances.
Training is particularly important because shoulder dystocia can occur unexpectedly, and an individual provider may have limited recent experience managing a complicated case.
Simulation provides opportunities to practice not only the physical maneuvers but also communication, teamwork, and escalation when initial interventions are unsuccessful.
Importantly, appropriate management also includes avoiding excessive traction and lateral bending of the baby’s head, which can place tension on the brachial plexus.
Training cannot eliminate every complication, but the research suggests that better preparation and adherence to recommended management techniques can improve outcomes.
What I Look for When Investigating a Brachial Plexus Injury
As a birth injury attorney, I have represented families whose children sustained brachial plexus injuries during delivery.
One of the most important questions in these cases is not simply whether shoulder dystocia could have been predicted.
It is what happened after the shoulder dystocia occurred.
When investigating these cases, I examine the sequence of maneuvers, the use of traction, the timing of the response, and the training and experience of the providers involved.
The delivery team must also be prepared to manage it appropriately, particularly when the initial maneuvers do not resolve the obstruction.
Not every brachial plexus injury is caused by negligence. And not every brachial plexus injury is preventable.
But that does not mean prevention should receive any less attention.
An unpredictable emergency does not automatically mean an unavoidable injury.
The Bigger Picture: Better Recognition and Better Outcomes
The research on shoulder dystocia presents two important developments.
First, reported shoulder dystocia rates have increased in several populations. Changes in maternal and fetal risk factors may contribute to that increase, but improved recognition and reporting may also play a role.
Second, studies have demonstrated reductions in brachial plexus injuries alongside improvements in shoulder dystocia training and management.
Accurately recognizing and reporting shoulder dystocia is essential.
So is ensuring that clinicians are prepared to manage it appropriately.
The goal is not simply to identify more shoulder dystocias. It is to recognize them promptly, respond effectively, and prevent as many associated injuries as possible.
Disclaimer
This article is provided for general informational and educational purposes only and is not intended to provide medical or legal advice. If you believe that you or a loved one may have suffered harm because of a delayed or missed diagnosis, you should consult a qualified attorney who can review the circumstances of your individual case and advise you regarding your legal rights and options.
References
- Youssefzadeh AC, et al. Incidence trends of shoulder dystocia and associated risk factors: A nationwide analysis in the United States. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics. 2023. Read study.
- Heinonen K, Saisto T, Gissler M, Kaijomaa M, Sarvilinna N. Rising trends in the incidence of shoulder dystocia and development of a novel shoulder dystocia risk score tool: A nationwide population-based study of 800,484 Finnish deliveries. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica. 2021;100:538–547. Read study.
- Mollberg M, Ladfors LV, Strömbeck C, Elden H, Ladfors L. Increased incidence of shoulder dystocia but a declining incidence of obstetric brachial plexus palsy in vaginally delivered infants. Acta Obstetricia et Gynecologica Scandinavica. 2023;102:76–81. Read study.
- Heinonen K, et al. Pitfalls in the diagnostics of shoulder dystocia: An analysis based on the scrutiny of 2,274 deliveries. Archives of Gynecology and Obstetrics. 2024;309:1401–1409. Read study.
- Draycott TJ, Crofts JF, Ash JP, et al. Improving neonatal outcome through practical shoulder dystocia training.Obstetrics & Gynecology. 2008;112:14–20. Read study.
- Crofts JF, Lenguerrand E, Bentham GL, et al. Prevention of brachial plexus injury: 12 years of shoulder dystocia training: An interrupted time-series study. BJOG. 2016;123:111–118. Read study.