What Is the Average Payout in a Birth Injury Case?

When families look up the average payout in a birth injury case, they’re often trying to answer a more personal question. If my child was injured because of the care they received, what could a lawsuit realistically recover? For some families, that means figuring out how they’ll pay for years of therapy, equipment or help at home. A multimillion-dollar jury verdict in the headlines may be the only point of comparison they’ve seen.

The published data can put those headlines in context. Some reports track compensation paid through settlements and after judgments. To understand what those payments tell us, it helps to look at whose claims were counted and whether the numbers reflect payments by individual defendants or a family’s total recovery.

What the available data shows

The average payment was about $1 million in two published analyses of paid claims relevant to birth injury. That figure gives us a rough sense of what was paid in those samples. One covers a single state and one year of closed claims. The other covers a broader category of newborn malpractice claims. Together they give us a partial picture of reported payments. The available figures do not establish a nationwide average for what families recover across all defendants. [1, 2]

 

Source and period What the source counted Reported payment
Ohio Department of Insurance, claims closed in 2023 [1] Ohio claim records identified by reporting entities as birth injury claims. Of 44 closed records, 23 had an indemnity payment. $1,081,196 mean among paid records
The Doctors Company, claims closed from 2008 through 2017 [2] Malpractice claims against physicians involving patients in their first month of life. The category includes allegations about delivery and other newborn care. $936,843 mean and $300,000 median among paid claims
Candello by CRICO, cases closed from 2008 through 2020 [3] Cases for which obstetrics and gynecology was the responsible service. The analysis reported that 41.4% closed with payment. $631,300 mean among paid cases
Schaffer et al., National Practitioner Data Bank analysis, 1992 through 2014 [4] Reported malpractice payments on behalf of OB-GYN physicians across allegation types. Researchers linked payment data to physician specialty information. $432,959 mean, adjusted to 2014 dollars

Ohio’s report counts records by provider or facility. If a family seeks compensation from both a physician and a hospital over the same delivery, Ohio can record two claims for that incident. The $1,081,196 figure comes from dividing $24,867,500 in indemnity by 23 paid records and rounding to the nearest dollar. It measures compensation reported on behalf of defendants and excludes the reporting entities’ separately tracked claim expenses. With only 23 paid records from one state and one closure year, a few large payments can materially affect the mean. [1]

The Doctors Company grouped claims by the patient’s age. Its newborn category includes allegations of delayed response to fetal distress and improper performance of a vaginal delivery, as well as allegations involving treatment of conditions such as sepsis and respiratory distress. The reported mean and median cover that broader newborn group. The study does not give a separate payment average for injuries sustained during labor and delivery. [2]

The other two figures describe a broader field. Candello classified cases by the service responsible, while the national study classified payments by physician specialty. Both approaches can include care outside the scope of a newborn birth injury claim, such as gynecologic care. The studies also cover different periods and use different reporting units. The national study explicitly adjusts amounts to 2014 dollars. Combining the figures or ranking them as if they measured the same population would obscure those differences. [3,4, 4]

What the National Practitioner Data Bank can tell us

The National Practitioner Data Bank (NPDB) collects reports of qualifying medical malpractice payments made on behalf of health care practitioners. Those payments can arise from settlements or judgments. Researchers can use the public file to study reported payment amounts and types of allegations. An obstetrics allegation code describes the allegation. It does not identify the practitioner’s specialty or isolate injuries to babies. Researchers who want to analyze payments by physician specialty need a separate source for that information. [4, 5]

The reporting rules also affect how researchers interpret the dollar amounts. Payments made solely on behalf of a hospital or other health care entity generally fall outside the NPDB’s malpractice payment reporting requirements. When a single payment benefits multiple practitioners and the payer cannot determine each practitioner’s share, the payer reports the undivided amount for each practitioner. [6,]

For example, suppose an insurer pays $900,000 on behalf of two practitioners and cannot allocate the payment between them. Two practitioner reports could each show $900,000. Adding the rows would produce $1.8 million from a single $900,000 payment. If the hospital separately paid $600,000 solely on its own behalf, that payment would generally be absent from the NPDB. The family’s combined recovery in this example would be $1.5 million. That is why neither the amount on a single report nor the sum of the reports necessarily reflects what the family recovered. 

Why verdicts, settlements and published case results are hard to compare

A jury verdict reports the amount awarded at trial. The amount ultimately paid can change after post-trial rulings, an appeal or a later settlement. A paid-claims report measures compensation paid under the source’s reporting rules. It may include payments after judgments as well as settlements. A figure described online as an “average settlement” may therefore be drawn from a source that combines both. [1, 6]

An online roundup of verdicts or a firm’s published case results represents the outcomes that were selected for publication. Without a defined set of cases and a consistent method of collecting outcomes, there is no way to tell whether that selection reflects the full range of payments. A large verdict can be accurately reported and still tell a reader very little about how often comparable cases resolve for that amount.

What determines the value of an individual birth injury case?

When I review a birth injury case, I start with the medical records and the child’s needs. Two children with the same diagnosis can have very different long-term needs. The evidence about what happened during labor, delivery or newborn care can also differ substantially.

  • The evidence of negligence and causation. Medical records, fetal monitoring, the timing of clinical decisions and expert review can help establish what care was required and whether different care would likely have changed the outcome. The strength of that evidence affects how the parties assess the risk of trial.
  • The child’s current and future needs. The evaluation may include medical treatment, therapy, equipment, home modifications and attendant care. When appropriate, a life care plan can identify the services a child is expected to need, how often they will be needed and what they are projected to cost.
  • The governing law and available sources of recovery. State law can affect the types and amounts of damages recoverable. The defendants involved, available insurance and other resources can affect how much of a judgment can be collected.
  • The difference between a gross payment and the amount a family receives. Published indemnity figures measure compensation at the level defined by the source. Attorney fees, case expenses and applicable reimbursement obligations can affect the amount ultimately available to the family.

If you have questions about your child’s care during labor, delivery or the newborn period, you can contact Liro Willer Law to request a free, confidential case review.

DISCLAIMER

This article is for general informational purposes only and is not medical or legal advice. Decisions about pregnancy and delivery should be made in consultation with your healthcare provider based on your individual circumstances

Sources

  1. Ohio Department of Insurance, 2023 Medical Professional Liability Closed Claim Report, Introduction and Appendix C, Exhibit 11
  2. The Doctors Company, Study of Malpractice Claims Involving Children, study design and payment tables
  3. Candello by CRICO, MPL Data Helps Validate Simulation Training
  4. Schaffer et al., Rates and Characteristics of Paid Malpractice Claims Among US Physicians by Specialty, 1992–2014, JAMA Internal Medicine, Table 3
  5. National Practitioner Data Bank, Public Use Data File Format Specifications, ALGNNATR
  6. National Practitioner Data Bank Guidebook, Reporting Medical Malpractice Payments
  7. National Practitioner Data Bank Guidebook, Reporting Payments Made for a Health Care Entity
Related Posts

Looking For Answers?
We Handle Personal Injury Cases

Contact us Now

What Our Clients Have To Say...